The Best Savings Accounts for Kids: Comparing 529’s, UTMA’s, Trump Accounts, and More.: True Riches Podcast Ep 2
Executive Summary

Every parent wants to provide meaningful opportunities for their children. But with so many different savings and investment accounts available, how do you know which ones make the most sense for your family?
Should you prioritize a 529 college savings plan? Open a custodial UTMA brokerage account? Take advantage of the new Trump Accounts? Or simply keep the money invested in your own name?
In this episode of the True Riches Podcast, Zack Gutches, CFP® and CPA, breaks down seven different ways parents can save and invest for their children’s futures, exploring the tax advantages, limitations, financial aid implications, and practical considerations of each.
Topics covered include:
- The seven primary account types available for saving for children
- How gift taxes work and the $19,000 annual gift tax exclusion
- The advantages of 529 plans, including tax-free growth, qualified education expenses, and Roth IRA rollovers
- Colorado’s 529 tax deduction and First Step matching program
- How grandparents’ 529 accounts can affect college financial aid eligibility
- UTMA accounts, the kiddie tax, and the trade-offs of irrevocable gifting
- How the new Trump Accounts work, including their tax treatment and potential Roth conversion strategies
- Why keeping investments in your own brokerage account may be an underrated option
- The importance of balancing tax efficiency, financial flexibility, and responsible stewardship
The takeaway: There isn’t one perfect account for every family. The right approach depends on your financial resources, goals for your children, and how much flexibility you want to preserve.
At True Riches Financial Planning, we help families navigate decisions like these by blending modern financial strategies with timeless biblical principles.
Learn more or schedule a complimentary introductory meeting at truerichesfp.com/contact.
Timestamps and Chapters
00:00 Introduction
00:44 Why Parents Should Save for Their Kids
02:01 The Seven Types of Accounts
04:27 Roth IRAs and Trusts for Children
06:25 Gift Taxes and the $19,000 Annual Exclusion
09:22 529 College Savings Plans Explained
13:28 Expanded Uses and Roth IRA Rollovers
17:12 Colorado’s 529 Tax Benefits and Matching Program
19:18 Grandparent-Owned 529s and FAFSA
21:31 UTMA Custodial Brokerage Accounts
24:14 UTMA Tax Benefits and the Kiddie Tax
28:07 How UTMAs Affect Financial Aid
30:11 Trump Accounts Explained
32:29 Trump Account Tax Treatment
35:31 FAFSA and Roth Conversion Strategies
40:11 The Overlooked Option: Your Own Brokerage Account
42:42 Final Thoughts
This podcast is intended for general financial education and should not be considered personalized tax, legal, or investment advice.
Podcast Player
Resources Featured In This Episode
Table of Contents
Full Transcript
Introduction [00:01]
Welcome everybody to the True Riches podcast, where modern financial planning meets timeless biblical principles. I'm your host, Zack Gutches, a practicing CPA and CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER® professional. I'm also the founder and lead financial planner at True Riches, a fiduciary flat fee Christian practice that provides a cohesive experience across financial planning, faith-based investment management, and personal tax return programs. As always, I like to remind everybody that this podcast is intended to serve only as general financial education and not personalized tax, legal, or investment advice.
Please be sure to speak with a qualified professional about your specific situation.
Why Parents Should Save for Their Kids [00:44]
On today's show, we're going to be talking about savings accounts for minor children. So we'll talk about the seven different main types of accounts that you can fund For your kids, I think all parents want to support meaningful opportunities for their kids, and so there's different types of accounts, each that kind of supports a different kind of opportunity, such as college education or retirement or maybe some unrestricted funds that could be used more versatility for things like a home down payment or a business startup or things like that. And I'm not unaware of the fact that for a lot of families, they don't have the extra margin financially to be able to do this planning ahead.
They're just trying to make it and get through and make sure that their kids have a reasonable higher education of some kind. But at the same time, I will say that those who have that capability, planning ahead really does pay off when it comes to these accounts. We've all seen Probably some version of the compounding interest chart. The earlier that you start funding these types of accounts, especially with some of them having certain tax advantages, actually the less money that you need to put in to have that needed dollar amount in the future for your kid.
The Seven Types of Accounts [01:59]
And so the seven different types of accounts that we'll talk through four of them today and then just a quick word on the residual three, but you've probably heard of some of these before, maybe haven't heard of all of them, but the first, probably most well-known Is the 529. The second is called a UTMA. The third would be these are brand new in the last year or so, but the Trump account The fourth option we'll talk about is kind of just keeping your own but maybe separate personal account but earmarking that account for your future kids. And then five and six are both setting up trusts for your kids, one revocable and one irrevocable.
And then last but not least would be the Roth IRA. And so I think it's kind of important just to step back and ask like why did these account, all these different account types exist in the first place? And like most things that are law related, tax law mostly is designed to motivate consumer behavior. Like if you own a home, right, you're getting potentially a tax deduction for your property taxes and the interest that you pay on your mortgage. That's the government, you know, utilizing tax law to help incentivize, you know, their people to own a home.
It's the same thing, right? There's, you know, for giving money to charity, there's a potential tax deduction for that. When you think about these accounts, it's the same way for our own personal retirements like 401ks or Roth IRAs. The government is viewing it from a liability perspective. They don't want to be on the hook for the main things that your kids are going to endure, like potentially higher education or vocational training or traditional college and their retirement. They're giving Tax incentives, which we'll explore in this, to each of these different account types to help incentivize and motivate consumers to put money into these accounts.
And then kind of on top of that, a second layer for miners specifically is, generally speaking, miners can't legally own assets in their own outright name. And so we have these special account types that we're talking about today where it's not directly owned by them or there's some sort of exception that applies that kind of gets around that.
Roth IRAs and Trusts for Children [04:17]
So let's maybe start with the three that we're not really going to talk about today in depth anyways, but just I'll share a quick word on each of them. So the last three, like the last one I mentioned on that, you know, option seven is the Roth IRA. And, you know, great account, would love it, but the main wrinkle in this account is you have to, the child has to have earned income from an actual job that they're paying taxes on and declaring for tax purposes to be able to put money into this account. So, I mean, the limit is $7,500 each year. A lot of adults are trying to max out their Roth IRA, but as we look to do so for our kids, they have to have that earned income.
So, if they earn, you know, $4,000 doing summer Lifeguarding, they're limited to $4,000 that they could put into their Roth IRA. And then for most of us, if your kids aren't at least 16 years old or so, they probably don't have that earned income that they're actually filing or paying taxes on where they could contribute. So that's why we're not going to talk about that one today. And then the other two are trusts. And there's definitely a handful of families that find themselves having the capability to fund a trust. Whether one would be revocable, that just means you can revoke what it said, you can change it along the way, and then one is irrevocable.
Typically, not always, but most often, these revocable and especially irrevocable trusts are more for the ultra-wealthy. As a way to, not necessarily an income tax play, but more so to shift money outside of their name so that the future growth on those dollars will grow outside of their own name and they won't get hit with estate tax. Again, something that very few families deal with, but if you pass away with about more than $15 million apiece, so for a married couple, about $30 million in today's landscape, you're subject to sometimes 40% plus estate taxes on them.
But for those of us, right, who aren't in that category, which is most households, you know, we've kind of got the other four as our primary default options.
Gift Taxes and the $19,000 Annual Exclusion [06:25]
And so I think it's important before jumping into the four different account types, you know, minor children funding actually requires a lot of knowledge in tax law and then estate law. And they're kind of connected at the hip. But those two. So I think it's important just to kind of start like, how does it work when you're actually giving money as a parent to to your kid? You know, so obviously providing the support that your kids need doesn't fall. That's not necessarily a gift. But when we're thinking about funding, you know, these different account types like a 529 or a UTMA or a Trump account.
Right. That requires they count that as a gift. And so kind of how they've. Gotten past it so that it's not super tedious and burdensome tracking is there's kind of an exclusion or kind of like an amount that you can gift from any one person to another person without having to do any sort of tracking or declaring it on your taxes. And that amount changes with inflation. It goes up over time. But in 2026, it's $19,000 from any one person to another person. So a lot of times if you have a kid, right, you know, the one spouse could give $19,000 to that kid and then the other spouse could give $19,000 for a total of $38,000.
Now if you give more, you can give more than $19,000. This is where most people, you know, don't think about this. It doesn't come into play, like I said, for very many folks. But you can give more than $19,000 in any one given year to someone, but then you need to declare it. And you usually declare that on a special tax form And you're basically just showing what you gave and how much it was worth. And then they're basically taking the amount that's above the $19,000 and they're just reducing that estate amount. That's the amount that you can pass away with in your name and not have to pay those estate taxes of call it 40% on it.
And so like I said earlier, it's about $15 million per person in 2026. It used to be a lot lower. It was only a couple million, maybe even, you know, two million. Then it jumped up to five. And then now we're at 15 million a person. So it's definitely the highest that it's ever been. But say you gave someone, you know, $100,000 in one calendar year. They would just, you know, you take out, you get the first 19 exempts, so the residual $81,000 then just eats into that $15 million in today's landscape. It is a bit burdensome to kind of file a gift tax return.
They're not very common, again, because not many people do this, but most people are going to be falling under that $19,000 per year. But that's kind of the maximum, with some exceptions, that you can typically do without having a tax reporting obligation. And so with all that out of the way,
529 College Savings Plans Explained [09:24]
let's jump into the four different types that we're going to talk about today. So the first, the most famous, you know, most people have heard of is the 529, right? This is the basically a Roth IRA for education or vocation related expenses. That's probably the best way to explain it. So you open the account and these are state sponsored accounts. So every state has their own 529. Some states offer you a small tax deduction for putting money in there. Some states like Colorado even have a match, a small matching program. Um, but you open an account through that specific state.
Um, they each have a 529 plan and then you as the parent or the adult, whoever's opening it is the owner of the account. But then you set the beneficiary of that account typically to be your kid, or you can have multiple accounts for each one of your children if you have several. And so the main idea with this account is you put money in, you're not really getting a tax break today. Again, absent, maybe a small, um, We'll see you next time. In certain states. But the main benefit of this account is all you know, you invest reinvest the money like you would in a 401k they've maybe got some different funds that you can pick from and all of the growth is going to be tax free it grows tax free while it's in the account And then as long as it's used for kind of education or vocation related expenses That money all comes out tax -free.
So it's kind of like a Roth, you don't get upfront tax benefits today, it grows tax-free. And then when you take it out, you're not taxed on it at that time. I've heard, especially as we've entered the AI era and kind of a change overall in the landscape of traditional college, some people are a bit nervous about overfunding these. And that can definitely be true for certain families if they're gifting a lot of money into these accounts each year. But I mean, my personal... Opinion is even in the AI realm, like I don't think higher education or, you know, higher vocational pursuit training is necessarily going to go away.
When these accounts first came out, the 529s, like they were very focused and limited more so just to your kind of traditional four-year college, but the rules have continued to evolve with the landscape. So, I mean, now you can use them for trade schools, vocation schools. You can even use it for on-campus housing if you're, you know, Enrolled in a accredited program and at least half time you can even use it for off campus housing. You can use it for certain tutoring expenses, books and supplies and software. AP, you know, prep exams, you know, higher like professional certifications like for me, like a CPA or CFP® certification, the ongoing continuing education requirements like they've just expanded so much that I think for most families who are maybe thinking about putting, you know, five to ten, fifteen thousand dollars a year into these accounts for the first few years, even with some healthy growth in there, you know, the average cost of college today is thirty thousand dollars a year.
So again, I think these are oftentimes the default and for good reason that, you know, I don't think vocation and getting training to be good at a specialized skill set is going to go away as a whole, even in the age of AI, it just might look a little different as to where we're getting That vocational training or education from but I think the laws, as we've seen have continued to evolve and will continue to evolve to kind of keep up with that. Because again, the government wants people to put money in these accounts, and they're willing to give them tax incentives to do so, so that they're not on the hook for them.
So I think these are really great. If you're going to start anywhere, this is oftentimes, you know, the best start for a lot of families.
Expanded Uses and Roth IRA Rollovers [13:28]
You know, they've even changed the laws lately, you know, and it is state specific. I need to call that out. Like Colorado is a good example of this. You know, so the recent law allows you to take out, it doesn't have to just be for college. If they go to private school, like K through 12, it used to be that you could only, you could use $10,000 per kid per year. And they actually just changed that to $20,000 per kid per year that you could use for private K-12 education. Again, Colorado, that's a good example where Colorado is an exception to that.
They do not conform to the federal laws around that. They view their 529 plan as solely for college or post-secondary school education. And then most plans allow for the federal law to use up to $10,000 per kid to pay off student loans actually after college is over. And then the last one that came into effect about four years ago or so is if you have some extra money in there, you can use up to $35,000 per kid and actually use that and kind of do a direct rollover, a tax-free direct rollover to your kid's Roth IRA. So you'd have to space it out over about five years, because the limit on a Roth is just over $7,000 a year.
The total limit is about $35,000, so that's about And that doesn't add to your ability or your kid's ability to put more into their Roth. It's just now your kids can use that, say, $7,000 they otherwise would have been putting into their Roth for something else because you can do this direct tax-free rollover from the 529 to the Roth IRA. And then you can change the beneficiary actually on the accounts too. So if people have multiple children and they're a little bit hesitant, I always like to bring up that, say you have three kids, maybe not all of them do end up pursuing the higher education route, but say two of them do.
So you can change the beneficiary from say your oldest kid to your middle or your lower or your youngest kid, and there's not really any tax implications of doing so. Now, if you do are gonna change the beneficiary across a generation, like to a grandkid, that's a different story, but within kind of the family and kind of within your, they even have some exceptions where you can do your cousin or in-law, things like that, and it doesn't necessarily trigger any tax or gift tax requirements. But with that said, if you do end up putting too much money into this account and none of your kids or even yourself, you could change the beneficiary yourself, but none of you end up using the amount I mean, you could just leave it for future generations.
They kind of call that a dynasty, you know, 529. But say you just want to, you know, most families don't find themselves in that. They want to take the money out. Then, yeah, you know, you're going to pay income taxes on the growth just like you would have if it would have been maybe in a different account type like a 401k, for example. And there is going to be a 10% penalty on the earnings portion as well. And I don't know the stats on it, but my presumption would be that that is pretty rare, that not a lot of families are taking the penalty and paying the taxes on putting too much money into the 529.
I'm sure it does happen, but my guess is it's not super prevalent. And the other thing I like about these is they're pretty easy to set up. Again, most parents want to support meaningful opportunities for their kids' education. I think most people would agree higher education is a worthwhile pursuit in some shape or form, whether it's traditional college or others. So I think it's a really good opportunity for a parent to support the meaningful opportunity for their kid in that way.
Colorado’s 529 Tax Benefits and Matching Program [17:11]
Like I said before, each state has its own specific rules and whatnot, but I'll talk about Colorado, given that's where I live. So, you know, they give a small state income tax deduction. So, you know, 4.4%, you put in $100, that would shave $4.40 off your taxes. So not a huge deal, but something small to consider. And then Colorado actually has a matching program called the First Step Program. It used to be they would match your contributions $1,000 a year for five consecutive years. Um, I guess enough people have taken advantage of it that now, uh, it's $500 for three consecutive years, but still that's free money.
You know, it's kind of like a free, it's like a 401k match. As long as you can afford to put in the 500 or a thousand bucks, I mean, that's absolute free money or a hundred percent return that you're getting without taking any sort of risk. Um, so that's a great option and just need to know are with Colorado and then just need to kind of know your state specific and you don't have to stay in the same state. Like I could live in Colorado. And open the Utahs. There's this called my529, for example, if I like maybe the investments within that 529 better than the investment options that are in my Colorado 529 plan, for example.
What's also nice about it too is it's easy for others to contribute to it. So most 529s like Colorado's, for example, when you have your account, you're in your portal, they have a link that you can, kind of a URL that you can copy and paste to grandparents or others who might want to Contribute to it. It's called Ugift and so they click that link and they can pick an amount, you know say a hundred bucks that they want to put in for a birthday or Christmas present and then they can put the money directly into that account so that they don't have to open a bunch of different accounts and then again it depends which state you live in whether you'll get a state income tax deduction for that or not so you have to look at your state specific rules and then the other thing is
Grandparent-Owned 529s and FAFSA [19:04]
They could open their own account, like a grandparent could. If they plan to put a lot more into it, they can open an account. Again, they're the account owner and then your minor child, so their grandchild would be the beneficiary. Now, there's a slight benefit to doing that under today's law. It used to not be this way, but a few years ago, they changed it so that for college aid purposes, they don't really look at The grandparents 529 account balance when they're considering whether you qualify for need based financial aid when you're filling out the FAFSA.
So the difference between a parent, you know, say I open a 529 for my kiddo, they're going to college, I'm filling out the FAFSA. Let's say my kid's account balance just for easy math is $100,000. So how the current formula works for financial aid is they're going to assume that I can use about 5.6%, it's 5.64% of that $100,000 per year to support the kid's education. So they're going to assume that I can use $5,640 per year. And accordingly, they are going to reduce potentially the amount of need-based aid That they're giving my child by $5,640 a year because I've got the assets and that's kind of just the formula, the percentage they use on this type of asset.
Whereas with a grandparents account, they're not going to be counting it at all. It just doesn't even get factored into the picture. And that could change going forward. You know, again, it used to not be that way. And so I wouldn't, you know, I probably am not of the opinion to need to open the account solely for that if a grandparent wants to open their own account or maybe they only get the state income tax deduction for that or whatever the reason, then that's fine. But I don't know, for me, it feels like a large administrative hassle if we're just talking about really small amounts that they're going to do anyway, just to kind of dodge that 5.64% for need-based aid, which for a lot of higher income families, they may not qualify for any need-based aid.
That doesn't mean you shouldn't fill out the FAFSA, most likely. That's a separate conversation. But again, hopefully the point stands that I'm trying to make there. So I know that was a lot on 529s and intentionally so just given it's the most popular and oftentimes lowest hanging fruit for most families. So I wanted to just talk about all the different angles of a 529 so you can be well informed.
UTMA Custodial Brokerage Accounts [21:32]
We can move on to the second one, which is the UTMA. So this is basically a statutory, they've kind of come up with a statutory template, if you will, to open this type of account for a minor. You as the parent, it's called a custodial account. So you as the parent make irrevocable gifts to it. So once you give money or you can actually contribute stock, like if you held Apple, for example, and it gone up in value, you can gift the Apple stock over to that account and it doesn't trigger a sale on it. Or you can give cash or mutual funds or ETFs or whatever.
So that's kind of a unique benefit. That's called contributing in kind, where you can just give the actual fund or stock directly without needing to sell it and pay taxes to transform it to cash if it had gone up in value. So the UTMA is basically just kind of like a brokerage account for a minor that the parent controls until they are the age of majority, which it's different by every state, but in most states, it's 21. So a lot of parents do like this because it's an unrestricted account. Now with that, we'll talk about the tax benefits that it comes with.
But they like it because it can be used for anything. It's not restricted to vocation related expenses like a 529 is, but it goes the other way too, right? It's completely unrestricted and it's an irrevocable gift to these accounts. And so, you know, I think all of us intend to raise our kids, you know, to handle money well and to steward money well. But at the end of the day, when we're talking about, you know, say a three-year-old, we're making these decisions about their future. We may not know if they're going to have the character and integrity and wherewithal to be able to manage a large sum of money wisely.
And so I just often caution people or have them think about that before putting large dollars into a UTMA because it is completely unrestricted. There's no take backsies. And then once they're 21, it just turns into your kid's own brokerage account, you know, with whatever's in it at the time. What's nice about these is a 529 is kind of like the equivalent of a 401k plan in that you have a preset pick list of funds. Usually there's not that many. Maybe there's 10 to 20 different funds you can pick from. They're all really well diversified, which is a good thing for a lot of families who don't want to do all the research or don't have strong opinions about investing.
But with the UTMA, it's kind of like a Roth IRA, like the In terms of investing in that, the universe is your oyster. You can have individual stocks in there. You can have ETFs or mutual funds or REITs or whatever you want in there. It's very flexible what you can reinvest in.
UTMA Tax Benefits and the Kiddie Tax [24:15]
The tax benefit of these is there's basically a tax-free zone of $1,350 per year. So that would be anything interest or dividends or say you bought a certain stock in there and it went up by $1,000. You could sell that stock. That's called a capital gain when it gained in value. And so there's kind of a tax-free zone of $1,350 per year. So what some families do, maybe they had a stock in their brokerage account, they shifted over to their And then they sell it up, say, $1,000. And there's kind of that tax-free zone. I think that's probably in place just for ease of reporting purposes.
Once you're over that $1,350 a year, you run into what's called the kiddie tax. And this is basically in place so that super wealthy people who are in high tax brackets don't shift all their money to their kids so that they can just take advantage of their kids' lower tax rates. So the IRS has kind of subsided that. And so once you're over $1,350, there's kind of a kiddie tax, if you will. I'd say the main... So with that, knowing those two limits and that it's unrestricted, I get when people want to put money into this account. I just, again, often caution people about not only the kind of effects that we talk about for stewardship, but at the same time, there's kind of a practical element.
Because once the income's over that $1,350, there's typically a requirement to file a tax return. Your child and a lot of people don't want to do that. So kind of just using as a proxy, like a globally diversified stock fund, like 60% US, 40% foreign companies, you know, the dividend rate's about 1.75% on that. So if you think about funding that much, if you just leave everything as is in that global stock fund as an example, The dividends will exceed the tax-free zone of $1,350 once there's more than about $77,000 in there, if my math is right.
So for a lot of families that want to do that, that's fine. It can be a good starting spot. But just knowing that there's going to be more complex reporting requirements from a tax perspective once you get beyond maybe $75 ,000 or $100 ,000 depending what you're ultimately investing in. Then I'd say the other unique maybe tax play benefit of this account is more longer term, right? If you have trust in your kid, right? And, you know, once they're an early adult, you know, call it age 24, you know, if you've invested in specific funds or stocks and they've gone up a lot in value and you've held them at least a year, you know, once you're an adult and paying taxes on your own and all of that, you file your own tax return, you know, you've got You've got income taxes on your wages like a W-2, but there's these preferential or kind of lower tax rates usually when you're selling stuff that are investments that have been held at least a year.
So once you're 24, you're typically not subject to the kiddie tax anymore. And a lot of times, even people who are doing pretty well at age 24, they're not making near as much as they're going to when they're in their 40s and 50s. And so for a lot of them, If they're not making a ton of money, there's actually an ability for them to sell those funds that have gone up in value potentially at a 0% federal tax rate. Now, they might have to pay state taxes. It depends on that. But usually federal taxes are the biggest thing to be aware of. So that's a potential strategy that people use these for as well.
And again, they're most often well-intentioned. They want to be able to support their kids with a down payment on a future home. Just given where the real estate, you know, kind of crisis is for the younger generation, maybe a car, just things that are more flexible, business pursuit, whatever it is that aren't specific, you know, college or retirement.
How UTMAs Affect Financial Aid [28:05]
But I'd say the biggest disadvantage, and this may not come into play, just depends on your situation. Is kind of how colleges view these accounts, you know, when they're figuring out need-based aid, you know, when you're doing the FAFSA. I was talking about the 529, that's a parent-owned asset. So they, you know, assume you can use 5.64% of the account balance to pay for college each year. A UTMA technically belongs to your kid. And, you know, they know that most often, uh, Kids with accounts come from more money, and so they are assuming you can use 20% of this account each year to pay for college.
And so keeping the same $100,000 example from my 529, the college, the FAFSA need-based formula is going to assume you can use $20,000 per year to pay for college, and they're going to reduce your amount of need-based aid accordingly from that $20,000 a year number. So that's definitely the biggest downside most likely is the college aid and then just being cautionary about the unrestricted nature of the account and potential tax reporting requirements if the interest dividends and gains in there gets above the $1 ,350. The UTMAs for most brokerages are like institutions is pretty easy to open.
Most of them you can do it Fully online, like a Fidelity or Schwab or Vanguard or something like that, they usually can do them fully online and they're pretty easy to set up and even link to your existing accounts if you have some there so that you can move money to them again. It is an irrevocable gift. That you shouldn't, you know, it's advised not to just based on how the forms are set up to be taking money back because it's an irrevocable gift, you know, to those accounts. So just, yeah, no take backsies once you've given the money in there.
So UTMAs can be a really good fit for certain families. Just definitely you need to be aware of these factors so that you can proceed with caution and know what you're getting into.
Trump Accounts Explained [30:09]
And then last but not least, we're going to shift over to the Trump accounts, which have been getting a lot of media attention. I think it's a bit overhyped. That's just my personal opinion. We'll kind of talk about why. But these are pretty much brand new that were created in 2025. And so basically any kid that was born between 2025 and will be born through the end of 2028, you know, they've basically gotten a promise from very wealthy billionaires to donate money to it in the treasury. You know, that you'll get a thousand dollars free money from the federal government.
And so that is something that most families have been taking advantage of if they had a kid that was born between 2025 or will be by the end of 2028. Get the free thousand bucks. You know, you go to their app, Trump Accounts, and open the account and claim it. There's actually a latest IRS... Ruling or treasury ruling that they opened, they auto opened a ton of accounts for all eligible minors. And so now there's kind of this, do you want to go claim it from a data security perspective, even if there's no money? And then, you know, that's kind of a toss up for every family.
But with the Trump accounts, there's a $5,000 per year limit. And these are basically an IRAs. Not a Roth IRA, we'll kind of talk about the mechanics here, but it's basically a kind of think of a traditional IRA for kickstarting your kid's future retirement, right? Once they turn 18, they kind of just transform into like an IRA that maybe you as the adult have if you've ever like rolled over a 401k like that before. And so when you put the money in or you go claim that thousand bucks, you do have to go claim the thousand dollars, you know, by opening the account and verifying their social security number and have their birth certificate and all that.
But once it is, it's reinvested typically into a very low cost U.S. broadly diversified fund. So right now, the only option that I'm aware of is the S&P 500. I think they're going to expand that to like a total stock market. So you get all whatever, 3,000 plus different U.S. companies that are publicly traded in there. So it's, you know, very low. And they're only allowing people that have or funds that the expense ratio, just meaning what you pay the ETF or mutual fund provider is 0.1%. So one tenth of one.
Trump Account Tax Treatment [32:27]
So the tax benefit, the reason that I think these are overhyped for the most part, they can have good usage for sure. Get the thousand bucks. But the tax benefits is you're not getting any tax benefit up front, which that's kind of the same as, you know, there might be a small one on the 529 or you can contribute in kind on a UTMA like we talked about. But the money that you put in, if you put in 5,000 bucks, you're not getting any sort of tax benefit today. And what you put in won't be taxed again in the future, but all the earnings, so if that 5,000 is reinvested in the S&P 500 and let's say it grows to 15,000, so no, you know, gone up 3X, it's gone up 10,000 bucks.
That $10,000 of earnings is going to be taxed as income either when your kid takes it out in their eventual retirement or as we'll talk about the main strategy that people have been using these are going to use these for is to convert the traditional IRA money in the Trump account to a Roth IRA once they're an adult. And again, kind of goes back to that UTMA conversation of they're going to convert and pay the taxes when they're a young adult because their income is probably lower. That they're probably in a lower tax bracket and then all the future growth will live in a Roth IRA so that all of it again will be completely tax free when they take it out.
Assuming they've abided by all the rules that apply to normal Roth IRAs. I think these are great in that it is a dedicated retirement account. Again, it's like education. Retirement is a thing that most families agree on. They would love to help support if they could for their kids. This is a dedicated IRA for minors and will turn into a regular IRA or Roth if they convert down the line when they're an adult. I think- We'll see if the laws change, but they're just a little bit more burdensome because how the taxes work for these is the money you put in, you've already paid taxes on.
So if you put in $5,000, you're not getting a benefit, but then all future growth is going to be taxed. So now you've got this blending between non-tax money and money that will be taxed. And so it's kind of like the backdoor Roth IRA, if any adults listening to this know about that, where you have to track that ratio on a specific tax form called 8606. And so that can just be burdensome year over year, especially, you know, once you think about transferring, you know, your kid becomes an adult and then they're doing it and now they're inheriting your 8606 and have to deal with kind of the rules around it.
So I just think it gets a little bit complicated that I just don't know if it's going to get the wide adoption that maybe it was hoped to. But I guess we'll just have to wait and see. These are really new accounts. And I do think that the rules, you know, they're so new. The rules have already been coming out every couple months. There's a new update on how to manage these accounts or how they're going to view these accounts from a tax perspective or legal perspective.
FAFSA and Roth Conversion Strategies [35:31]
We're still waiting on for college aid, for example, how they're going to view these. There's some... People that live in the camp that, well, it's a student asset. You know, it's a minor IRA. It's owned by the student. And so it should be assessed that 20% per year of the account balance for college aid purposes. And then there's other people that kind of live in the camp of, well, technically it's a dedicated retirement account. It's an IRA, which under current FAFSA, it doesn't count. Like retirement assets don't count. They haven't come out and clarified that.
People are speculating on both sides. I see both. I don't know which it'll be. But I'd say the main strategy for these is people are going to put the money in. They're going to wait until their kid is 24. They're probably going to be in the 12% federal tax bracket, which is a pretty low bracket. If they're making, say, 50 grand a year in their first job, They could then convert an additional, call it $15,000 or $16,000, just what you had put in. Say you'd put in $5,000 over three years. Remember that $15,000 could be moved over to a Roth IRA tax-free.
You've already paid taxes on it, but then they'll move some of the earnings over so that they stay within the 12% federal bracket just as kind of an example. But again, when you go to convert the Trump account, the regular Trump IRA to a Roth, it's that pro rata rule. So if you put in $15,000 and it grew to say $45,000, it tripled, only one third of every dollar that you convert is not taxed. The other two thirds that's earnings is taxed when you do the conversion to the Roth IRA. So Again, I think a lot of people will just claim the thousand bucks.
And, you know, if that grows, I call it seven or 8% for several decades, whether, you know, if they're retirement, like that could be 10,000 bucks or whatever. I haven't done the math. It could be a fair amount of money. Now, the thing that I kind of find that's cheating when I see this on social media is people show these projections of how many millions of dollars or how many thousands of dollars these are going to be. And they're not wrong, but they're not converting it back to inflation adjusted dollars. Like if you think about 30 years ago, somebody was a millionaire.
That was a huge deal. Whereas in today, you know, a million dollars doesn't get you near as far. It doesn't really mean that much if you are. I mean, that's a good milestone, but it's not like you're an ultra wealthy person if you have a nest egg of a million bucks anymore. And so it's the same thing. And they're always running these projections again to their kids age 60, their retirement. So it's like if inflation averages 3% a year, the purchasing power on the numbers that they're showing is just not going to be what we think it's actually going to be.
If they show it's going to be worth $50,000, that's great, but that doesn't get you $50,000 worth of purchasing power in today's dollars. So to put a bow on the Trump accounts, I think I've seen in practice the most people that are using them is those that are already putting a meaningful amount towards a 529. They've kind of That's kind of the first checkbox, if you will. But if they want to do above and beyond that, they're also taking advantage of the Trump account because it is a lower limit. It's only the $5,000 per year, whereas in a 529, technically, there are limits, but most people, you're just subject to the annual gift exclusion limit that we talked about earlier, so $19,000 from one person to two.
So for a married couple, that's $38,000 per year. They could put into each of their kids 529s, whereas the Trump account, it's just $5,000 per year per kid. And unlike the 529s where say a grandparent can just open their own account, you know, you can't, you're not supposed to do that with a Trump account. And there could be, yeah, you're not supposed to do that with a Trump account. So you need to just coordinate and make sure no one other than the legal guardian, they show it on the tax form when you open the account, but it's really only the legal guardian is supposed to be opening the Trump account.
And so I just think it's a lot more administratively burdensome for it. It can definitely make sense for certain families that, But just more complexity with the tax tracking. And then I'd say the last thing is different states have decided to potentially tax the distributions differently. They don't conform to the federal law. And so you'll have to check your individual state. Most are at this point. Some have said they're not sure yet, but then there's a handful that have said they're not going to conform to the federal tax law treatment of these accounts.
The Overlooked Option: Your Own Brokerage Account [40:13]
And then the final one, which is not its own separate or dedicated, you know, minor account, but I think it's one that's underrated, quite frankly. And, you know, this isn't personal advice whatsoever, but, you know, this last one is where I fall into at least for a portion. And I think that's important to call out too, is a lot of people just kind of think they have to go all in on one. And if you're doing just really small amounts, that's probably best. It's just very, a lot simpler to keep track of. But I also think some people just think I have to go all 529 or all Trump account and you can kind of do.
A mix of both, right? You got to coordinate and make sure you're not going over the gift exclusion limits that I've talked about a few times. But another option, and that doesn't involve any gifting now, is just keeping it in your own accounts. Maybe you open, say you have a joint brokerage account where your existing non-retirement assets live, but you could just open another joint brokerage account and you transfer money from your existing one over to that one and you've kind of mentally earmarked That separate joint brokerage account for your kids.
Even though it stays in your own name, what I think the biggest benefit is, you just preserve the flexibility. All these other accounts have tax benefits associated with them because they can only be used for certain things. There's all these rules. That's what we've been going over. But if you're just keeping it in your own name, yeah, you're not getting the tax benefits, But at the same time you're still doing the intentional planning of trying to support meaningful opportunities for your kids and you've just given yourself a lot of flexibility which like we've talked about before um you know we a lot us want to we want to think that you know we'll raise great kids and they're going to want to steward the money really well and they are going to have great abilities to do so but that's just not the reality that we always live in And so, And I wasn't that way, you know, at age 18 or 21, like most 18 and 21 year olds are not.
Well-equipped to be able to handle large sums of money or know what it means or just, yeah, again, how to handle it well. And so, yeah, there's less tax benefits with doing so, but I think that's a good hybrid or even dedicated option that you can do. Just open an own separate account, have the kids as the beneficiaries in case something happens to you. You know the money goes to them, whatever you've named in your will or whatever or trust if you have an estate plan set up. I think it's a really underrated option. So I know that there's a lot of options.
Final Thoughts [42:44]
And honestly, I went a lot longer than I intended to. This is a completely unscripted podcast to just take quick little breaks to drink water. But at the same time, you know, I was trying to do as in depth of a deep dive into each of them just off the top of my head is for everybody so that you could just feel well informed. And I know that being a new parent can just be overwhelming, right? Your life kind of changes. And then you kind of think about the financial implications of that and just reshifting your priorities in life. And so if that's you, you're wanting someone that specializes in working with young families and those raising a family maybe don't have the time, the expertise or the energy or even the desire to manage all of this, feel free to reach out to me.
Go to our website at truerichesfp.com slash contact and we'll see you next time.
Author: Zack Gutches, CPA, CFP®
Zack Gutches, CPA, CFP®, is the founder of True Riches Financial Planning, a fee-only, fiduciary financial planning practice based in Denver, Colorado. True Riches serves Christian families with biblically grounded financial planning, faith-based investment management, and personal tax preparation for one flat fee. On the True Riches Podcast, Zack explores how modern financial planning and timeless biblical principles fit together.
DISCLAIMER: The True Riches Podcast, its show notes, and its transcripts are intended to serve solely as general financial education and not personalized investment, tax, accounting, or legal advice, nor an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security. Before considering acting on anything you hear or read here, first consult with your tax, legal, or investment advisor about your specific situation.
Any case studies, examples, and projections are hypothetical illustrations only. They do not represent actual clients or actual investment results, are based on assumptions that may not come true, and are not a guarantee of future results. Individual results will vary.
All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Any reference to a specific company, security, fund, or strategy is for illustration only and is not a recommendation to buy or sell.
Tax laws, contribution limits, and regulations change often. Information is believed to be accurate as of the recording date but may become outdated, and its accuracy is not guaranteed.
Books, websites, products, and services mentioned are shared for convenience and educational purposes only and do not constitute an endorsement. True Riches Financial Planning is not responsible for the content of third-party websites.
Opinions expressed are those of Zack Gutches as of the recording date and are subject to change without notice. Discussions of Scripture and faith reflect his personal beliefs.
Transcripts are generated with automated tools and edited for readability, so they may contain errors. The audio recording is the authoritative version.
True Riches Financial Planning LLC is a registered investment advisor offering services in the State of Colorado and in other jurisdictions where exempt from registration. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. More information about our services and fees is available in our Form ADV Part 2A.
Christian Financial Planning to Invest, Give, and Live Abundantly.
Reach out for a complimentary "good fit" consultation.

